“The difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter.

It’s the difference between the lightning bug and the lightning.”

Mark Twain

Editing Services

  • Manuscript Evaluation

    $.005 per word.

    This type of feedback is sometimes called a manuscript analysis or an editorial letter. If you are on a tight budget or aren’t sure your book is worth the effort and money required for full edits and publication yet, you can request this as a stand-alone service, but it is also included in my Developmental Edit package.

    This is a lengthy report (I haven’t delivered one yet that was less than twenty pages.) covering personal impressions, data analysis, and suggestions for how to improve your story at the “bird’s eye” level. The goal is to provide a roadmap you can follow throughout the revision process that will help you keep the big picture in mind.

  • Developmental Edit

    $0.02 per word

    This comprehensive breakdown of a story, also commonly known as a substantive or structural edit, includes my Manuscript Evaluation service.

    After completing the report, I comb through the manuscript looking for opportunities to implement guidance given in the report, scene-by-scene.

    I strive to ensure that your story’s structure is tight and effective, that each scene serves the plot, that your pacing is timely, that your characters are in character, that your promises are kept, and that your resolutions stick their landings with satisfaction.

  • Line Edit

    $0.02 per word.

    This line-by-line focus (sometimes called a content edit) is where we polish your prose, turn a phrase in the right direction, and align the reader’s understanding with the author’s intent.

    Line editing transforms words into art. Fight scenes get punchier. Characters find their voices. Colors, smells, tastes, and textures gain definition. And the dreaded white room is made over as a place the reader wants to crawl through the page to inhabit.

    After I return my suggestions and you make revisions, I take a second pass at the manuscript for additional grammar, spelling, and other technical corrections (i.e. “light” copyediting or pre-copyediting).

  • Complete Editing Bundle

    $.038 per word

    Manuscript Evaluation

    Developmental Edit

    Line Edit

    Light Copyedit

    A total of four editorial passes, each with its own focus, gradually panning from the biggest nuggets to the finest details.

  • Add-on Service: Series Catch-up

    $50

    Does your book require context to be fully appreciated because it’s not the first in a series? I’m happy to read as many books as needed to see the big picture. This is a valuable add-on if you want me to understand where your characters have been before I make any calls about where they are or where they’re going.

  • I read the story start-to-finish, noting my thoughts and reactions as I go.

    Then, I re-read, summarizing events chapter-by-chapter, and constructing an outline I can use to examine the story’s structure and plot progression. I check the outline for clues to pacing issues, missing story beats, unnecessary side plots, incomplete character arcs, and so on.

    Next, I write a one-page analysis of each chapter, highlighting its strengths, weaknesses, and suggestions for improvement.

    I also recommend learning resources based on the areas where I see the most room for improvement.

    Turnaround Time: 5,000 words per day; five days per week, Monday-Friday.

  • The first step in this process is to complete a Manuscript Evaluation. I expand on the basic version of this report by analyzing each scene, striving to ensure that it is “load-bearing” to the story.

    Once I complete my written report, I dive deeper into the story by making notes throughout the manuscript, pointing out opportunities to add or remove scenes or flesh out sections that feel incomplete (lacking description, action, character motives, etc.) and recommending passages that can be removed or relocated to improve flow.

    I pay attention to each scene's purpose. I offer suggestions on how to improve dialogue, prose, tone, setting, pacing, conflicts, tension, and stakes. I also check for inconsistencies, illogical reasoning, and factual errors. I look for missing information or elements, and I note redundancies. I also examine character arcs, world-building, timelines, narrative voice, tropes, and themes across the length of the entire novel.

    Turnaround Time: 5,000 words per day; five days per week, Monday-Friday.

  • This phase focuses on prose, semantics, tone, character and narrative voice, dialogue, description, action, readability, and streamlining your word count. It’s where we strive for flow in your narrative’s stream of thought.

    I do broad searches for words that bloat the prose: fillers, filters, and weak verbs/descriptive words. This can significantly reduce a book's word count while strengthening your voice.

    Next, I examine each scene and pick through each paragraph, checking for intent, tone, description, character motives, conflicts, relationship dynamics, voice, and readability. I search for ways to enhance these elements or balance them by adjusting syntax and semantics. I cut out repetitions, trim the fat, and re-arrange the order of ideas and events as needed to make each scene flow.

    Turnaround Time: 5,000 words per day; five days per week, Monday-Friday, for each pass (once for line edits, and once for light copyedits).

  • This service can be added onto any other editing service. It is not a stand-alone service.

    I charge a flat fee of $50 for each book you want me to read other than the one I am providing feedback on. I do not give feedback on any of these books. This service is purely to provide context for the book I am working on and enable me to view the story through a wider lens.

    Each book will extend the project’s deadline by one week.

  • My specialty is the art and craft of storytelling, which is within the purview of high-level edits. Copyediting and proofreading are about technical correctness in language.

    I am trained in the conventions of copyediting and proofreading, but this is not my focus when doing a developmental or line edit. I do correct grammar and spelling errors as I go, but I do not go out of my way to double-check for compliance with CMOS or other style guides, nor do I provide a stylesheet as a dedicated copyeditor should.

    I will return a very clean document that has had the majority of errors corrected, but I recommend seeking the services of a skilled copyeditor and proofreader after you have made revisions based on my feedback because making changes always introduces new mistakes.

  • “Illy is an exceptional line editor! You’ll never feel worse about your writing than when you get a critique back from her—in the best way. I’ll spend so much time trying to make sure I have a clean draft and then get it back from her absolutely ripped to shreds. And then, as I pick up all the pieces, I find that it’s way better than it was before! What do you want to bet she’s going to edit the errors out of my review?”

    Shelley G.

    contemporary romance, Jane Austen retelling, post-apocalyptic, urban fantasy

  • “Illy is a fabulous and thorough editor. She picks up quickly on the context, language, and vibes of your work and matches her edits to them. She is bossy and ruthless and will never pull punches, which is everything I need as an aspiring author. I’m very grateful for the work she has put into my writing and am highly satisfied with the results.”

    Ani M.

    action/adventure, YA, twisted fairy tale

  • “You’ve given me a WEALTH of extremely valuable points to consider! I’m so grateful for your thoughtful critique. I didn’t want a stranger to pat me on the back, tell me they loved it, and allow me to make a fool of myself in the court of public opinion. Thank you for respectfully finding ways to tell me my manuscript is not ready for line & copyediting. Without a doubt, I could’ve been taken advantage of. It’s through your honesty that I know my work and name are safe. So thank you for being someone who’s TRUSTWORTHY! Everything you’ve given me is valuable, including every word of encouragement! Your evaluation is exactly the type of feedback I needed, but it took receiving it for me to realize that. Again, I thank you for your professional input.”

    Tiffany T.

    contemporary romance, Jane Austen retelling

  • “What great work, plowing through this. I’m frankly amazed at the patience it takes to noodle through such a document and fix it. I could never have done it. I thank you once, I thank you twice, I thank you three times for your wonderful help.”

    John C.

    memoir, spirituality

  • "Illy provided helpful and encouraging feedback on my children’s picture book. She was friendly, quick to respond, and delivered in a flash. Pleasure working with you, Illy!"

    Joey Benun

    (children’s picture book—Pebbles and the Biggest Number)

Which editing service is right for your book?

The uncomfy truth:

All of them. Just not all at once.

There’s a reason there are so many stages in the editing process. Many authors claim they can’t afford multiple services, but if you want a publishing-house-quality book, your manuscript needs to go through all the same stages of refinement a publishing house provides. Making a book the best version of itself takes time, ingenuity, and a village—much like raising a child. You’ll get the best final result if you enlist multiple editors, each with their own phase of the process to focus on.

Stephen King

“Only God gets it right the first time, and only a slob says,

‘Oh well, let it go.’”

Let’s make some magic together.